Iran’s IRGC appoints Assadi to support Assad in Syria

IRGC Brigadier General Mohammad Jafar Assadi
IRGC Brigadier General Mohammad Jafar Assadi

According to  a report from inside Iran by  the National Council of Resistance of Iran, the  Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC), following the large number of IRGC casualties in Syria, especially the death of General Hossein Hamadani, commander of the Iranian regime’s forces in Syria, and injury to Commander of the IRGC Quds Force (QF) Qassem Soleimani, Ayatollah Khamenei appointed  IRGC Brigadier General Mohammad Jafar Assadi  the IRGC commander in Syria.

Assadi is one of the most veteran commanders in the IRGC and a close associate of Major General Mohammad Ali Jafari, Commander in Chief of the IRGC . Assadi has many years of experience of involvement  in the affairs of countries in the region. In Syria, he is known as Abu Ahmad.

Assadi  joined the IRGC in March 1980 and was one of the commanders of the war with Iraq. He was commander of the IRGC in Lebanon from 2003 to 2007 and then commander of the IRGC Ground Forces from 2008 to 2009. In October 2015 he was appointed commander of Imam Hossein Base that is responsible for organizing ‘Imam Hossein’ battalions that are tasked with domestic suppression. But very shortly afterwards he was transferred to Syria and IRGC Brigadier General Gholamhossein Gheibparvar replaced him as the commander of Imam Hossein Base, the NCR report added.

According to the report  , since signs of the  Iranian regime’s failure in Syria became evident, Khamenei and IRGC commanders reached the conclusion that the Quds  Force ( QF)   alone cannot control the situation and the IRGC as a whole needs to enter into the war . However the   control of the situation politically as well as the command of the Lebanese Hezbollah and Iraqi militias  remains with the QF.

Prior to the Russian air strikes, the Iranian regime and Qassem Soleimani himself vowed  that if the Russians initiate their  operations , IRGC would quickly retake the regions that Bashar Assad had lost in Aleppo and Homs. On October 5, 2015, a few days after the initiation of Russian aerial bombardment, Qassem Soleimani and Hossein Hamedani met with Khamenei and got his approval for ‘Moharram’ operational plan. According to the plan, the regime’s forces were to take back Aleppo from the opposition forces by October 24, 2015. However, on October 8, Hossein Hamedani was killed. Subsequently, Qassem Soleimani got stationed in Syria and assumed command of the Moharram Operation, but  he too was wounded  and the plan turned to a fiasco.

Following successive blows to the IRGC in southern Aleppo in October and November, a number of IRGC commanders wanted to retreat from Aleppo to other sections in Syria to avert further casualties. However, Khamenei told IRGC commanders in a meeting that Aleppo is vital to the regime and thus they are not allowed to retreat from there, but they should change their methods and tactics. For this purpose, the regime shuffled some forces in southern Aleppo, but no forces have been removed from Syria and the IRGC has no such plan.

Considering the blows and defeats of the past three months, the IRGC has arrived at the conclusion that it needs to change some of its tactics. Instead of handing over the areas that it occupies to the Assad army, the IRGC is handing them over to the Shiite militia forces affiliated with it such as the Syrian Jaish al-Vatani or Hezbollah because the Assad army has not been able to hold onto these areas and has been  quickly losing  them back to the Syrian opposition forces resulting in high casualties to the IRGC and Bashar Assad’s forces.



123 responses to “Iran’s IRGC appoints Assadi to support Assad in Syria”

  1. 5thDrawer Avatar

    ASSad & Uncle ASSadi … Great Combined set of heads.
    El Supremo says: ‘You must Hang .. In. Returning is not an option.’

    1. Hind Abyad Avatar

      Why do we need more Zionists on YaLibnan.

      1. 5thDrawer Avatar

        Ummm … because barely anyone else is hanging around? Lebs seem to have given up on the project begun here. But then there were a lot of good ideas put forward, and no-one listened.
        Might as well have a couple of Israelis to not listen to. :-)))

        1. Hind Abyad Avatar

          They are fed up of trolls..take it it’s all yours. Bye.

        2. Hind Abyad Avatar

          You want to know why as a Christian as a Lebanese i was against the war on Syria since my arrival here?

          This post below is by a Zionist on Al-Monitor..and believe me they planned it they create it since 1915. Jabotinky was the editor of Ataturk paper “Young Turks” that promoted the Armenian Genocide, Sharon Begin Likud, the invasion of Iraq. Now we the original Christians from where civilisation was born, are the “Native American” and Zionists are the “European arrival in “America” .
          Thank you for never believing me and thanks all who called me Iranian, Hezbpig.. as i said take it it’s all yours..”soft Zionist”. Bye

          -“It is written in the Christian Scriptures ” There is a time to every purpose under heaven”.This means that every tribe or religion has an appointed time to their rise and subsequent fall.The Christian Era in the Mid-East is now over, just as the era of the ” Native American ” ended with the arrival of the Europeans in America. While the various Islamic States are required to protect the “Resident Alien”/Christians, residing among them, these aliens must respect their Islamic rulers and accept the Islamic Law as the Law of the Land.The Islamic World will be forced to accept a new reality at some point in the future, as all others before them have, sad but true”.

          1. This Islamic revolution has been labeled as the Islamic Inquisition many times. The history of the world is full of invasions and conquests.

            Hard to compare Zionists in a small, very small area of the ME to North, South America, Australia, Asia and even Europe. How can 8M people be so disruptive to 7B.

          2. Hind Abyad Avatar

            Shut UP!!

          3. NO.

          4. Hind Abyad Avatar

            You’re such an ignoramus pest with your stupid talking points.

          5. I don’t here any rebuttals other than “shut up”. I would love to hear how 8M in Israel is a total disruption to the remaining 7B of the world.

          6. 5thDrawer Avatar

            We’ve already proven how … 10 of your Bankers own the rest of the world’s money.
            Even yours. Too simple, really.

          7. The Rothschild or Zionist Banker thing again. I can just feel the Jewish media domination in the air. Pfffffft.

          8. 5thDrawer Avatar

            Don’t forget the ‘All-Seeing-Eye’ at the top of the Pyramid when you say ‘Pfftt’.
            God’ll getcha if you don’t watch out. //\ There ARE 2 possibilities.
            Armageddon will occur when they call in all the loans at the same time.
            OR ..
            The world just kills those 10 and carries on as if nothing happened.
            ‘Choose Wisely My Son’.

          9. 5thDrawer Avatar

            (Modern Methodology …. Everyone gives the Bankers the Middle Finger and laughs.)
            (Immortalized as the ‘Laugh Clown Laugh’ response.)

          10. Then the Christian Bankers must be laughed at continually.

          11. 5thDrawer Avatar

            For ‘Following The Rules’ .. Yes.

          12. Cop out due to religious orientation?

          13. 5thDrawer Avatar

            Come to Canada … Different System.
            (Of course this is fucking our Dollar on ‘International Levels’ … But we are not living in FEAR and ANGST, thank God/Great Spirit/Brainiac.) (AND we have Bacon.)

          14. Hind Abyad Avatar

            Monsanto GMO facility nearly destroyed in possible arson attempt in France


          15. Your point?

          16. Hind Abyad Avatar

            You support our poisoners.

          17. Who are the poisoners?

          18. Hind Abyad Avatar

            Monsanto familly..and The following Jews were known dealers, owners, shippers or supporters of the slave trade and of the enslavement of Black African citizens in early New York history.
            Issack Asher, Jacob Barsimson, Joseph Bueno, Solomon Myers Cohen, Jacob Fonseca, Aberham Franckfort, Jacob Franks, Daniel Gomez, David Gomez, Isaac Gomez, Lewis Gomez, Mordecai Gomez, Rebekah Gomez, Ephraim Hart, Judah Hays, Harmon Hendricks, Uriah Hendricks, Uriah Hyam, Abraham Isaacs, Joshua Isaacs, Samuel Jacobs, Benjamin S. Judah, Cary Judah, Elizabeth Judah, Arthur Levy, Eleazar Levy, Hayman Levy, Isaac H. Levy, Jacob Levy, Joseph Israel Levy, Joshua Levy, Moses Levy, Uriah Phillips Levy, Isaac R. Marques, Moses Michaels, (E)Manuel Myers, Seixas Nathan, Simon Nathan, Rodrigo Pacheco, David Pardo, Isaac Pinheiro, Rachel Pinto, Morris Jacob, Raphall Abraham Sarzedas, Moses Seixas, Solomon Simpson, Nathan Simson, Simja De Torres, Benjamin Wolf, Alexander Zuntz

          19. Keeping a list. Your hatred runs deep. Would you care to supply the Christian slave owner names since this is all about slavery? I would doubt you have that info. You simply confirmed that your nothing more than a racist/bigot of the Christian variety. A disgusting example of what so many good Christians despise. A pity that that there are so many of you.

          20. 5thDrawer Avatar

            Truth runs deeper. Seek and ye shall find.

          21. Just did. Don’t hide behind a book, I’ve heard it too many times.

          22. 5thDrawer Avatar

            Rather Illogical, if everyone is extrapolating information from the ‘One Book’, called a Torah, and then theorizing that the theories of the One Book are correct when nothing has been proven beyond ‘human nature’ by it.

          23. The book is also called the Bible.

          24. 5thDrawer Avatar

            What the hell did you think I just said ????
            Add the next one, and then the next … there are a variety of them by this time.

          25. You said the Torah. There’s been a “edit”…..remember.

          26. Hind Abyad Avatar

            Keep it it’s yours.. five books and dust..

          27. Not mine, but the Bible has it.

          28. Hind Abyad Avatar

            Who cares..go rest

          29. Now the Bible is insignificant to you.

          30. Hind Abyad Avatar

            Over the past several hundred years, the convergence of a mountain of evidence points to the human component of the Bible. There are parallel texts from other traditions (the 22nd chapter of Proverbs for example, parallels almost exactly an Egyptian text written centuries before)…………………….

          31. MaImequer0 Avatar

            Another conspiracy??? ☻☻☻

          32. Hind Abyad Avatar


          33. Hind Abyad Avatar

            For a non Jew and atheist he’s very interested in religion…haha

          34. Hind Abyad Avatar

            John Newton; “Amazing Grace”!
            Now shut up i don’t keep a list, it’s in history…..(dishonourable history)

          35. NO. I called you out and no song is going to change that and I will never “shut up”.

          36. 5thDrawer Avatar

            Someone else kept the list. Hind just hates that few look for it.

          37. I’m pretty sure this “Rebeka Gomez” was quite a valkyrie.
            P.S. It rarely takes long for these “anti-Zionist, not anti-Semite” characters to show their true colors. In the end, their mental/verbal incontinence always overrides any restraints they might have.

          38. 5thDrawer Avatar

            French farmers have their ways …. remember when they dumped truck-loads of sloppy manures on the political site of supposed excellence?? What a hoot. :-)))

          39. Hind Abyad Avatar

            Governments are not going to force poison on french farmers.

          40. MaImequer0 Avatar

            Have you been hit by a skunk truck sweetie???

          41. Hind Abyad Avatar


          42. Sure, the robotic sharks and vultures, the all seeing eye under every bed and in every closet, Pfffft. Plus your Biblical and nonsensical prose.

          43. Hind Abyad Avatar

            ..and you bomber..

          44. 5thDrawer Avatar

            Call him ‘Doubting Rudy’ henceforth. … 😉

          45. Biblical reference???

          46. Hind Abyad Avatar

            Ask Bibi

          47. Why?

          48. 5thDrawer Avatar

            Bank Floor Sweepers check paperwork at night.

          49. Posted notepads left over the floor. Sounds like any office.

          50. 5thDrawer Avatar

            See? You DO understand after all. :-))

          51. Understand than posted notepads are in every office? That’s common knowledge and common in any office.

          52. 5thDrawer Avatar

            Spies know it. (They even pay Floor Sweepers … under the table, of course.)

          53. Yup and every major country has them.

          54. Hind Abyad Avatar

            MONSANTO Family Were Jewish Slave Dealers And Owners
            The Jewish Monsanto Family of Louisiana included Benjamin, Isaac, Manuel, Eleanora, Gracia and Jacob. They made frequent purchases of Blacks including twelve in 1785, thirteen and then thirty-one in 1787, and eighty in 1768.

          55. zzzzzzzzzz. How many Christian slave dealers and owners have the centuries endured?

          56. Hind Abyad Avatar

            Jewish slave traders switched to population enslavement and poisoning.
            Christian farmers refuse to eat Monsanto shit. Don’t mess with French agriculture.

          57. The US slave trade was Christian.

          58. 5thDrawer Avatar

            Africans were the collectors and sellers. And everyone just loves ‘sales’.
            (The Biggest was a Queen …)

          59. Slavery has existed for centuries to the current day.

          60. 5thDrawer Avatar

            Yes. And in the end, it’s only about how the slaves are treated that makes some feel fine, or others barf.
            These are simple concepts .. it’s curious that some people wish to ‘debate’ the whole’ of several concepts ‘ad infinitum’, while never attempting to modify any.

          61. In the end it’s about slavery….period.

          62. Hind Abyad Avatar


          63. 5thDrawer Avatar

            Which IS ‘Business’. Not Theology.
            Humans varied over their evolutions in how they did business – and varied in how quickly they accepted some better approaches to it. Still do.
            The slave is a useful tool to the owner. Only. But a dead one doesn’t work.
            SO, there is a cost factor involved if work needs to be done. Initially, food, a roof, and warm clothes depending on the environment, as well as general health being taken into consideration – value placed on muscle-mass in early times. (too bad if born a weakling – no meds) Here are examples of the ‘names’ used – after the ‘simple slave’ at earliest concept. There are varieties of these….
            Serf; Indentured Servant; ‘Company-Store’ Dependent; Labourer; Worker; Skilled worker; Wait-Staff; Office Worker; Lower-to-Upper Management (a Walmart ‘Fave’ system) … (and as Dad always said, one step up is one step closer to the door.)
            There is nothing ‘new’ … a few owners, and many slaves.
            The DIFFERENCE is in the view that they may also be human and have a contribution to make to ‘a society’ BEYOND what the muscles can do for the owner.
            SOME noticed that ‘owners’ were generally not smarter than them, and made ‘Craft Unions’ to protect their better skills … and that too was an evolution, since the early ‘apprentice’ was a litteral slave for the Journeyman Crafter.
            And what I am saying, since I seem to need to explain everything in minute detail ….
            It’s BUSINESS. Has nothing to do with a God-Belief in any way, shape or form.
            To Become a ‘FREEMAN’ is a goal many have, and few attain, until Death frees them.
            Even Billionaires have this curious perplexity to consider.
            It is only in the mind.

          64. Hind Abyad Avatar

            In same years as the Monsanto slave traders, an English man named John Newton renounced his former slaving profession by publishing a blazing pamphlet called “Thoughts Upon the Slave Trade.” The tract described the horrific conditions on slave ships. The pamphlet was reprinted several times and sent to every member of Parliament. Under the leadership of MP William Wilberforce, the English civil government outlawed slavery in Great Britain in 1807.
            John Newton wrote “Amazing Grace”. Monsanto till today is “Amazing disgrace”.

          65. 5thDrawer Avatar

            The case for education. Most had never thought about the whole process.
            Teaching about Monsanto Methodology now is important. Knowing some truths, moreso.

          66. 5thDrawer Avatar

            See?? Again you were not surprised. You really DO know. You just come to bug Hind. 😉

          67. Know what??? Common knowledge???

          68. 5thDrawer Avatar

            (At this point, ‘Doubting’ will be given nickname …. Dud.)

          69. You are talking common knowledge about spies. Is this a new revelation for you???

          70. Bombs away.

          71. Wait, I forgot my tin-foil hat ! Must resist.

          72. Hind Abyad Avatar

            All hasbara got their mendacious tin-foil hat and a tube of crazy glue.

          73. MekensehParty Avatar

            8 of these banks went down in 2008
            if they truly own the world’s money first they wouldn’t have gone down, second the world would have been bankrupt.
            The myth of Zionists owning the world is not true, it’s a conspiracy theory promoted by the Arabs to justify their never ending defeats against a few million Jews

          74. Hind Abyad Avatar

            “The Arabs” were not in Europe were the Rothschild financed both sides of Warring Monarchs for centuries.


          75. Hind Abyad Avatar

            In 1815, Nathan Mayer Rothschild made the following statement:

            “I care not what puppet is placed upon the throne of England to rule the Empire on which the sun never sets. The man who controls Britain’s money supply controls the British Empire, and I control the British money supply.”

          76. Oh do tell where Rense found this 200 year old quote.

          77. Hind Abyad Avatar

            “Who controls the issuance of money controls the government!”
            Nathan Meyer Rothschild.

            (Same thing as edited Wikipedia: ‘Deleted paragraphs’).

          78. The so called quote is from Ellen Brown’s book, “The Web of Debt”, who does not have a source for her quote other than her imagination.

          79. Hind Abyad Avatar

            Of course..

          80. Go beyond your bias and you will find Ellen Brown.

          81. Hind Abyad Avatar

            To go to your bias? I don’t need anyone

          82. You will find Ellen Brown and the rebuttal of her false claim.

          83. The quote is in the article. As far as the assassinations of those Presidents………I’m waiting for the alien angle, the conspiracy interpretations are dull and boring. BTW, did you about the Canadians being involved with JW Boothe?

          84. Hind Abyad Avatar

            “Canadian and U.S. authorities were working together closely by late 1864, passing information back and forth in an effort to foil the espionage efforts. Canadians did not want to be drawn into America’s Civil War and came to resent that “Thompson’s” harassing actions were conducted from bases in their country”
            Loyalists to Vietnam deserters crossed to Canada……

          85. I’m quite sure you are correct. I heard that Canadian “theory” two years ago. I didn’t believe it then and don’t believe it know. Just another example of how far some folks will go for their 2 cents.

          86. 5thDrawer Avatar

            Did you hear about the Canadian Wheat Farmer who didn’t want Monsanto seeds, and didn’t use them – but when the guy on the next farm used them (because the ‘push’ was in some pricing gimmick) some of the seed blew over a fence-line and grew as it will. Then at market-time, all of a field being harvested (hard to avoid a few wind-blown plants here and there), Monsanto ‘charged’ the guy who didn’t buy their crap with ‘theft’ and trying to sell it in a market – which ‘tests’ the genetics of a plant.
            APPARENTLY they believe they have a ‘licence’ on NATURE.

          87. Hind Abyad Avatar

            That poor man..”American Legal thinking”. American Greed.


          88. 5thDrawer Avatar

            So … Gotta Like their Health Insurance Plan, eh? :-))))
            Insurance companies and lawyers do .. 😉

          89. Have you not heard of the “Golden Rule”?

            Those who have the gold, makes the rules. It has always been this way. Their own levels of compulsion and compassion may vary though.

          90. Hind Abyad Avatar

            That’s the opposite of the Christian Golden Rule.

          91. MaImequer0 Avatar

            Wow sweetie, a new conspiracy?

          92. Could you give the short version? Reading her logorrheic posts in full is beyond my ability.

          93. 5thDrawer Avatar

            And would that be an example of the educational ‘dumbing-down’ ?
            Are you one of the victims?

          94. No, it wouldn’t. And don’t you worry about my victimhood. I can live with it pretty well :-).

          95. 5thDrawer Avatar

            I only ask, like a survey, to aid in filling my charts&graphs. 😉

          96. Feel free to use any of my material in your research :-).

          97. 5thDrawer Avatar

            I do .. as a ‘comparative’ … when you actually put some some of your own material.

          98. Hind Abyad Avatar

            The new YaLibnan squatter..he likes it here

          99. 5thDrawer Avatar

            Hind. As you say, Ignoring Mal-Mucky is easy.
            And I never said I don’t believe there have always been human slow-brains who accept anything ‘stated’ from anywhere as a ‘de-facto’ concept … especially when someone they ‘like’ says it, or a bunch in the same tribe say they invented it. This is not different than ‘prophetically announcing’ the end of the world … science backs up (has since star-gazers really began watching) THAT because it’s a fact, that some day the Sun will burn out. And Einstein showed the reason why, with calculations which gave more accuracy to the time-line, than trying to figure out when ‘Night’ would finally defeat ‘Day’ – or when an upset god would decide to give the chariot horses a break and sleep in to spite us all.
            Of course, now the ‘Great Hope’ is that the whole Galaxy doesn’t get sucked into a Black Hole for recycling, before our Sun burns out. We like to ‘believe’ this is improbable.
            And Religion is the Science of Improbability.
            (see Hitchhiker’s Guide To The Galaxy for ‘Improbability Drive’.)(The Guide is a Better Book)

            So, it is not that I, or many others afraid to say it, don’t believe you. I do. The improbability of humans actually existing is a concept which huge majorities still have trouble getting their heads around. They ‘need’ a ‘reason’ to exist. Looking wildly for one by creating ‘concepts’ which fly in the face of Natural Reality becomes their life’s work and fills the empty spaces in the brains. They ‘feel’ better for it – while ignoring how everyone else feels, of course. And this too is a Natural Phenomenon.
            And yet, it is impossible for them to, as John Lennon said, just ‘Let It Be’.
            SO…. They Create. All kinds of concepts, even besides religions. I don’t have space to list them all here since ‘recording history’ began … Label them ‘isms’.
            AND, what they fail to find in ALL cases is ‘Perfection’ by ‘Creation’. And why? They are not actually capable of being gods – even if they can imagine several.
            And for that reason, no matter what they come up with about trying to make everyone in ‘the same image’, it will not happen. Hasn’t really at any time in history, even if at times a huge crowd of more-lazy ‘seekers’ hangs on the false words of spouted theories and feels better for it.
            There are actual imperfections … naturally. Continue to point them out, but Let them be.
            Simple Truths.

            There is a High Probability that Humans will not exist as long as the Dinosaurs did, since they are among the least capable ‘beings’ of nature who can survive right out of the seed or the egg or the belly. And even their ‘societies’ require they help each other.
            I contemplate it would be good to ‘come back’ as a Dandelion … They get their heads chopped off all the time, yet can pop out a new one before the grass beats them … and if allowed to go to seed, just fly on the wind to anywhere and settle in comfortably, even into cracks in broken concrete. Almost perfection, by letting it be, the cycle repeats.

          100. Hind Abyad Avatar

            I predicted what will happen at that time there was no War yet in Syria.. it was in 2011.
            First raped massacred cut in pieces left on street corners, for the dogs to feed on, were the Christians in Homs, by the Syrian MB “rebels”. Now i let it be.

          101. 5thDrawer Avatar

            As someone said: ‘Banks don’t think in terms of a lifetime. They think of Centuries.’
            (the rest us are stuck with 60 years, and only 40 productive ones)

  2. The new General has the benefit of knowing two strategies that should not be used.

  3. “Considering the blows and defeats of the past three months, the IRGC has arrived at the conclusion that it needs to change some of its tactics. Instead of handing over the areas that it occupies to the Assad army, the IRGC is handing them over to the Shiite militia forces affiliated with it such as the Syrian Jaish al-Vatani or Hezbollah”

    This is the best part. We are not retreating, we are leaving the position in the hands of those poor Hezbullah bast*rds, let them take the blame and fight to the death to hold the area. Iran will not be handing (retreating) areas and letting SAA Assads men hold it, it is up to you Nasrallah, good luck with you newest group of martyrs.

  4. johngilbert Avatar

    Let’s not forget that Iran is currently hiding Soleimani from view due to injuries or death.

    1. Iran’s mullahs have taken many big hit in upper management. It is getting harder to get the younger gen to martyr themselves for the Islamic revolution they have been working on for the last 37 years. Peace seems more elusive than death unfortunately.

  5. johngilbert Avatar

    What do you call a supporter of ASSad? An ASSadi.

    1. Hind Abyad Avatar

      What do you call a die hard Malmequer0? johngilbert..

      Cook2half 9:49 a.m., Wednesday July 30 ….”Look what i found…same phase…same person..
      johngilbert is Malmequer: you can see him in my message box, but on yaliban it’s Guest. 2 weeks ago johngilbert, posted: “that girl HIND in really annoying”

      Goo night, i’m just going to bed”.

      1. It seems Cook2half holds a special place in your heart if your going to quote him after 5 months.

        1. Hind Abyad Avatar

          Cook was a Zionist friend the time. None of your business.
          You lurking bomb

          1. Boooom. LOL.

      2. MaImequer0 Avatar

        Wow sweetie, just wow…. take your meds.☻

        1. She should take them all at once, down them with a bottle of scotch, and THEN go to bed.

  6. ^Old men declare war.But it is the youth that must fight and die^! Hoover

  7. Patience2 Avatar

    The name is so close, why don’t they just replace Bashar with this guy?? Or, is that the plan???

    1. 5thDrawer Avatar

      It’s an idea .. :-)))

    2. Only with the help of a really good plastic surgeon.

      1. Patience2 Avatar

        Well, maybe a shave, ski-sanding and a really artistic nose job??

Leave a Reply