Analysis: Lebanon walks Syria tightrope

Share:

By Roula Khalaf

A year ago, Lebanon was bracing for trouble.

With Syria’s uprising raging next door – and politics in Beirut divided along pro and anti-Syrian lines – many assumed it would be a matter of time before the country was wracked by a spillover and Shia and Sunni began tearing each other apart.

Yet against all odds Lebanon has muddled through, with bouts of anxiety quickly subdued by politicians who have, rather unusually, recognised the potentially devastating impact of importing the Syrian crisis.

To some extent, the unlikely truce has to do with the experience of the 1975-90 civil war and the fear of what would be another sectarian conflict.

It also underlines recognition by Hizbollah, the pro-Syrian military group and the main backer of the government in Beirut, that its priority lies in maintaining the status quo.

“We are at the edge of the abyss and we’re not falling – that takes a lot of strength,” says a government ally.

It would be impossible for Lebanon not to be affected by the Syrian conflict. The economy has suffered from contagion and the bank are under pressure from a US administration determined to ensure that they abide by the sanctions against Syria.

Syrians are moving to Lebanon in droves – many more than the figure of over 20,000 registered refugees suggests.

Some stay with relatives or friends, others with the hundreds of thousands of Syrian workers who have been in Lebanon for years.

Most worrying are regular, often unreported, clashes along the Lebanese borders with Syria and allegations that Syrian regime forces have crossed into Lebanon in pursuit of opposition fighters.

A cameraman for a local television station was shot by Syrian soldiers on the Lebanese side of the border in early April.

Some Syrian activists in Beirut, meanwhile, have been threatened, although the pressure appears to have eased in recent months.

The Lebanese government, led by businessman Najib Mikati, has neither thrown its weight behind Syria’s regime, nor opposed it. It has walked a fine line with its policy of “dissociation”.

It has excused itself from Arab League decisions on Syria. It has been trying to balance the Syrian regime’s demands for a clampdown on arms smuggling for rebels with international and Gulf Arab pressure for greater support for the opposition.

So while the Lebanese navy was said last month to have intercepted a shipment of arms and ammunition apparently destined for Syrian rebels, the government has turned a blind eye to Free Syrian Army fighters who have taken refuge in the northern city of Tripoli.

“It’s not easy to keep the balance,” says a senior government official.

“But regionally we can’t go against Syria; nor can we be for it entirely because we would upset Gulf states and we need their support for our economy,” he explains.

On the domestic front, Hizbollah has been an open supporter of the regime of Bashar al-Assad since the start of the revolution. Syrian activists claim the Shia group has been helping the crackdown on the mostly Sunni opposition.

But Syria’s crisis has also put Hizbollah on the defensive, forcing it to contemplate the prospect of a collapse of a leading regional backer.

When it comes to policy against Syria, Hizbollah has lost the support of Lebanon Druze chief Walid Jumblatt, who has become one of the most strident critics of the Syrian regime.

If a political crisis broke out over Syria and caused the fall of the Mikati administration, it is not clear that the Shia militant group would have sufficient parliamentary support to form another government.

Paul Salem, head of the Carnegie Middle East Centre in Beirut, says Hizbollah has no interest in rocking the boat and neither does Lebanon’s opposition, led by a Sunni party.

He cautions that with parliamentary elections coming next year, the polarisation could intensify.

Lebanon’s balancing act could yet become a lot tougher.

 

Financial Times

Share:

Comments

22 responses to “Analysis: Lebanon walks Syria tightrope”

  1. persepoliswarrior Avatar
    persepoliswarrior

    the problem is that half of Lebanon has allegiance to a dictator in Damascus.  With this mentality, Lebanon will never be free of Syria’s grip of influence.  unfortunately, my fellow Shias in Lebanon have been completely brainwashed and some of the Christian Lebanese are pro-Syrian because they follow this idiot Aoun who is buddies with Assad.

    1. breakthemould Avatar
      breakthemould

       All parties should recognize that Syria is the lung through which Lebanon breathes. Regardless of who runs Syria, we are always influenced. We have no choice. Let us just hope that wise head prevail.

      1. 5thDrawer Avatar
        5thDrawer

        Well, the ‘lung’ has TB from sucking Syrian air for too long. There’s not much time left before it will need a transplant … if it doesn’t want to go back to 1975 status. The ‘wise heads’ only seem to be in decline.

      2. Hannibal Avatar
        Hannibal

        That lung is cancerous and should be removed even if the patient should die as a result… A new Lebanon should be born without the influence of the Persians nor the bastards of Timorlank (i.e. Syrians). It is a shame that midget Aoun forgot what the Syrians have done to his troops after he tucked his tail and ran to France… Here is a reminder: http://www.liberty05.com/civilwar/civil5.html
        All of you Syrian allies out there if you have an ounce of loyalty to your country rethink your alliance.

  2. persepoliswarrior Avatar
    persepoliswarrior

    the problem is that half of Lebanon has allegiance to a dictator in Damascus.  With this mentality, Lebanon will never be free of Syria’s grip of influence.  unfortunately, my fellow Shias in Lebanon have been completely brainwashed and some of the Christian Lebanese are pro-Syrian because they follow this idiot Aoun who is buddies with Assad.

    1. breakthemould Avatar
      breakthemould

       All parties should recognize that Syria is the lung through which Lebanon breathes. Regardless of who runs Syria, we are always influenced. We have no choice. Let us just hope that wise head prevail.

      1. 5thDrawer Avatar
        5thDrawer

        Well, the ‘lung’ has TB from sucking Syrian air for too long. There’s not much time left before it will need a transplant … if it doesn’t want to go back to 1975 status. The ‘wise heads’ only seem to be in decline.

      2. That lung is cancerous and should be removed even if the patient should die as a result… A new Lebanon should be born without the influence of the Persians nor the bastards of Timorlank (i.e. Syrians). It is a shame that midget Aoun forgot what the Syrians have done to his troops after he tucked his tail and ran to France… Here is a reminder: http://www.liberty05.com/civilwar/civil5.html
        All of you Syrian allies out there if you have an ounce of loyalty to your country rethink your alliance.

  3. wargame1 Avatar
    wargame1

    As soon as Assad is gone or about to  be falling ,Lebanon will get those Syrian Lackey , it is inevitable , yes its a matter of time. It will be nice to see Lebanon on its own , free and happy. Many changes are coming but few obvious changes are …Hezbollah and Iran´s bossing around will be over and the Hezbollah flunkeys will pack their bag and baggages for unknown location. However this is not going to be a cake walk but people will be inspired when they see Syria is becoming free from the psychopathic Killer. Its a matter of time ….

    1. Hannibal Avatar
      Hannibal

      Look at this wargame: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LPaX7VlZsks&skipcontrinter=1
      I think Sharon is an angel compared to the Hyena.

  4. wargame1 Avatar
    wargame1

    As soon as Assad is gone or about to  be falling ,Lebanon will get those Syrian Lackey , it is inevitable , yes its a matter of time. It will be nice to see Lebanon on its own , free and happy. Many changes are coming but few obvious changes are …Hezbollah and Iran´s bossing around will be over and the Hezbollah flunkeys will pack their bag and baggages for unknown location. However this is not going to be a cake walk but people will be inspired when they see Syria is becoming free from the psychopathic Killer. Its a matter of time ….

    1. Look at this wargame: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LPaX7VlZsks&list=FLObymnvXfeXWiscW4VhvivQ&index=2&feature=plpp_video&skipcontrinter=1
      I think Sharon is an angel compared to the Hyena.

  5. 5thDrawer Avatar
    5thDrawer

    Already happening in Tripoli … and the ‘NEWS’ never reports exactly how people are being affected there either. Tripoli Star is even 3 days behind most times … nothing is ‘up-to-date’ and often watered down, or not even reported. Nothing ‘gets out’ to that different country called Beirut … which has demonstrations for secular gov’t and women’s rights instead, and more electricity than anywhere else. BBC last item on Tripoli was April 27 … and I’m sure Al-Jazzera is afraid to send anyone now.
    Apparently even the LAF is afraid to be seen now … and some folks are sleeping on the streets in that city of fear.
    And ALL Tripolians are living in fear of waking them up. NO LAW is being enforced by the LAF.

    The biggest laugh in this article is “… the main backer of the government in Beirut …” referring to Hezzys. Backer??

    1. Hannibal Avatar
      Hannibal

      Hey 5th,
      Look at this… It is unbelievable…
      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LPaX7VlZsks&skipcontrinter=1

      1. 5thDrawer Avatar
        5thDrawer

        Yah … I had heard about it … maximize the torture. 
        keep the gun pointed too … just in case. Filmed as an example to spread the fear.
        All they spread is loathing ….

  6. 5thDrawer Avatar
    5thDrawer

    Already happening in Tripoli … and the ‘NEWS’ never reports exactly how people are being affected there either. Tripoli Star is even 3 days behind most times … nothing is ‘up-to-date’ and often watered down, or not even reported. Nothing ‘gets out’ to that different country called Beirut … which has demonstrations for secular gov’t and women’s rights instead, and more electricity than anywhere else. BBC last item on Tripoli was April 27 … and I’m sure Al-Jazzera is afraid to send anyone now.
    Apparently even the LAF is afraid to be on the streets at night now ….

      1. 5thDrawer Avatar
        5thDrawer

        Yah … I had heard about it … maximize the torture. 
        keep the gun pointed too … just in case. Filmed as an example to spread the fear.
        All they spread is loathing ….

  7. dateam Avatar

    well what do people out there think of this opinion…? i believe the syrian issue will go on for some time…at least till after the american elections….the syrian crisis now is no different than the iran iraq war that went on for 8 years and no different than the lebanese civil war that went on for ages….they cant get to hezb…they cant afford to go to war with iran…so by forcing this on syria they can keep them occupied long enough to weaken the chain….its the same old story of conquer and divide…the west knows they have noone credible enough to replace assad…they also know that if he falls it could lead to a major civil war with broadening outcomes that noone can afford…and they also fear that it will strengthen the salafi grip on the conuntry….look at libya…look at egypt god knows what will happen there??
    what do peope out there think?

    1. 5thDrawer Avatar
      5thDrawer

      Basically dateam, it’s a world of shit … some of it rather old.
      I’m sure most people do not want to go back to 1975 … but they are still under a gun in Liban. And obviously (for protection) every group has a little store-room with their weapons at the ready. True disarmament would mean little  – although it would change stuff like 10-yr old kids running around ready to shoot anything that moves the wrong way. Some would bring out the swords instead.
      It’s the minds of people which need to change.
      Standing up to be counted doesn’t mean you need a gun too. It means a willingness to have peace. To insist on it from the politicians.
      And any country that sits on the fence now, having seen a year of what happens in Syria, has not stood up to be counted as part of a more humane age. If it only sat on the fence and said nothing it would be better than taking sides – yet we see them allowing sides to be taken by some groups, and not in simple statements but by threats and more threats that ruin the peaceful lives of all. And that’s because no-one believes in equality, even if there’s a supposed system of government which pretends equality exists under the ‘Confessional Parliamentary Democracy’.

  8. dateam Avatar

    well what do people out there think of this opinion…? i believe the syrian issue will go on for some time…at least till after the american elections….the syrian crisis now is no different than the iran iraq war that went on for 8 years and no different than the lebanese civil war that went on for ages….they cant get to hezb…they cant afford to go to war with iran…so by forcing this on syria they can keep them occupied long enough to weaken the chain….its the same old story of conquer and divide…the west knows they have noone credible enough to replace assad…they also know that if he falls it could lead to a major civil war with broadening outcomes that noone can afford…and they also fear that it will strengthen the salafi grip on the conuntry….look at libya…look at egypt god knows what will happen there??
    what do peope out there think?

    1. 5thDrawer Avatar
      5thDrawer

      Basically dateam, it’s a world of shit … some of it rather old.
      I’m sure most people do not want to go back to 1975 … but they are still under a gun in Liban. And obviously (for protection) every group has a little store-room with their weapons at the ready. True disarmament would mean little  – although it would change stuff like 10-yr old kids running around ready to shoot anything that moves the wrong way. Some would bring out the swords instead.
      It’s the minds of people which need to change.
      Standing up to be counted doesn’t mean you need a gun too. It means a willingness to have peace. To insist on it from the politicians.
      And any country that sits on the fence now, having seen a year of what happens in Syria, has not stood up to be counted as part of a more humane age. If it only sat on the fence and said nothing it would be better than taking sides – yet we see them allowing sides to be taken by some groups, and not in simple statements but by threats and more threats that ruin the peaceful lives of all. And that’s because no-one believes in equality, even if there’s a supposed system of government which pretends equality exists under the ‘Confessional Parliamentary Democracy’.

Leave a Reply