Protests have died but Lebanon’s trash disaster is alive and piles are growing


In this Thursday, Dec. 17, 2015 photo, a car passes by a pile of garbage in Karantina, east Beirut, Lebanon. Lebanon’s trash collection crisis which set off summer protests is entering its sixth month, but you would hardly be able to know it in Beirut. (AP Photo/Bilal Hussein)
In this Thursday, Dec. 17, 2015 photo, a car passes by a pile of garbage in Karantina, east Beirut, Lebanon. Lebanon’s trash collection crisis which set off summer protests is entering its sixth month, but you would hardly be able to know it in Beirut. (AP Photo/Bilal Hussein)
By PHILIP ISSA and Zeina Karam ( contributor)
Lebanon’s trash collection crisis which set off huge protests this summer is entering its sixth month, but you would hardly know it in Beirut.

Not only are the capital’s streets kept relatively garbage-free, but the country’s politicians have been in no hurry to resolve the catastrophe.

Instead, trash is pushed to the periphery, piled in hills near the mouth of the city’s river, attracting a fly infestation that has plagued Beirut’s easternmost residents since early November.

On the other side of the river, trash mounds along the bank reach the height of roadway overpasses.

“The situation is disastrous,” said Rachid Rahme, a physician at Lebanon’s Sacre Coeur Hospital. “I don’t like to get involved in politics, but I’m sure they could find a way to deal with it rather than dealing with it in this way.”

The latest initiative to solve the crisis, a proposal to export the waste temporarily, was approved by the Cabinet following a marathon six-hour meeting Monday evening, despite complaints by some ministers about its exorbitant cost.

Prime Minister Tammam Salam emerged after the meeting, telling reporters that the pressing need to “end this nightmare” forced the government to resort to this option until a more lasting solution could be found.

Still, it will likely be at least several weeks before implementation of the export plan starts.

Frustration over the mounting garbage sparked a protest movement under the banner “You Stink,” an epithet aimed at the government, which brought tens of thousands of demonstrators into Beirut’s streets over the summer. The collection crisis erupted in July after authorities closed the primary landfill for Beirut and the surrounding coastal governorate without providing an alternative.

The demonstrations were a catharsis of discontent directed at the political class, which has walled itself off from popular opinion and failed to provide other basic services such as water, electricity and drainage.

But those protests have largely fizzled out, owing to a mix of canny political maneuvering and repressive crackdowns.

In September, young men openly identifying themselves as supporters of the country’s Parliament speaker descended on the protesters, carrying knives and throwing punches and stones. The security forces withdrew. Every time demonstrators attempted to approach the parliament building, security forces fired their weapons into the air, sprayed tear gas and water cannons, and arrested dozens.

To a country still accustomed to spasms of violence, twenty-five years after the formal conclusion of its civil war, the threat of disorder scared protesters off.

“The political authorities played it smart to defuse us,” said Assad Thebian, one of the organizers behind the politically unaffiliated campaign.

The state’s fastidious efforts to keep the capital’s streets clean also helped pacify the population.

Agriculture Minister Akram Chehayeb, one of the architects of the trash exporting plan, says the country has no choice but to export after a tortured national process to open new landfills collapsed.

“There’s no trust in the government, so the people refused to accept sanitary landfills. And until we restart government institutions and elect a president, we are stuck with the most expensive solution,” he said.

The country has not had parliamentary elections since 2009 and has failed to elect a president since 2014.

With over one million war refugees entering Lebanon from neighboring Syria since 2011 and the country’s parties openly allied with rival sides in that conflict, Lebanon’s politicians say they have to move cautiously to preserve the fragile political balance.

A few municipalities have launched their own recycling initiatives, but many others are simply burning their garbage, often in residential areas. Air contamination in these areas is now more than 400 times worse than pollution in the country’s industrial areas, a recent study by the American University of Beirut revealed.

Rahme said the consequences can be disastrous and already gastroenteritis cases are up 30 percent since last year.

“There are other diseases that can happen … It can cause cancer in the long run and asthma in the short term,” he warned.

Associated Press



5 responses to “Protests have died but Lebanon’s trash disaster is alive and piles are growing”

  1. 5thDrawer Avatar

    If you can’t see it, it doesn’t exist … Baabda Rules.
    Like Tripoli … A city that can’t be seen from Beirut … women hide away with their skin problems too … and Mikati hides on his estates in London … while Hariri’s promised new homes for the bombed&burned out become collecting places.

    1. Hind Abyad Avatar

      Hariri is the Garbage Company man that started this in the first place.

      1. 5thDrawer Avatar

        Hind .. To be fair, the Elder found a solution for his time, and in a fairly short 5 years had some things working and being cleaned up. He had to work among and with the thieves and war-lords to accomplish anything – he used the ‘system’.
        While Seeking the changes (looking forward), ‘someone’ bombed him out of existence.
        We have no idea if anything could have changed under him.
        And after that, nothing changed; except it caused the one wonderful moment like the Christmas Football match and food exchanges in WWI – ALL the sect’s had people standing together and chanting for a few days .. ‘ASSAD MUST GO’.
        Unfortunately, there were 2 things they didn’t realize.
        Iran had moved in with Hezzys, and ASSad only took out the army.
        And when there was ONE election, Junior may have been riding on Dad’s coat-tails (sounds familiar) when he ‘won’ the position, but how much time did he get? 6 months?
        So I note his broken promise …. but it’s difficult running anything when it’s too dangerous to be at home … and that ‘system’ is still in place. Nothing changed.

        1. Hind Abyad Avatar

          He was Saudi’s man.

          1. 5thDrawer Avatar

            Anybody can make a mistake … although the ‘commanders’ didn’t help much.
            Implementing a ‘good plan’ is key to any success. Losing the ‘surprise’ factor is bad.
            In WWII, Dieppe was another one of those things … Battle of the Buldge another, which almost succeeded for Hitler.
            Wars are like big chess games … the pawns always used up when needed.
            Interesting that Churchill decided, after defeat, to then find out what it was like to be one of the pawns.

Leave a Reply