Syrian civil war shakes Damascus-Beirut ties

Share:

The Syrian civil war has spilled over into Lebanon, bringing with it sectarian street clashes, mob violence and general government paralysis in Beirut.

But it was the dramatic arrest earlier this month of a former Lebanese government minister and prominent supporter of Syria’s embattled president that has suggested the conflict may be causing Lebanon to slip further away from Damascus’ long domination.

The bloodshed in Syria has drawn Lebanon deeper into the unrest – a troubling sign for a country that has gone through its own 15-year civil war and has an explosive sectarian mix as well as deep divisions between pro- and anti-Syrian factions, many of which are armed.

The chaos could give Sunni Muslim fighters in northern Lebanon more leeway to establish supply lines to the rebels inside Syria in their battle to oust President Bashar Assad.

Tensions and intermittent fighting in the northern Lebanon city of Tripoli continued Wednesday following two days of clashes between pro- and anti-Assad groups that killed at least six people and wounded more than 70.

Seventeen times bigger than Lebanon and four times more populous, Syria has long had powerful allies here, including the Iran-backed militant Hezbollah group that now dominates the government. For much of the past 30 years, Lebanese have lived under Syrian military and political domination.

That grip began to slip in 2005, when former Prime Minister Rafik Hariri was assassinated in Beirut. Widely accused of involvement_ something it has always denied – Syria was forced to withdraw its troops. But the killings of anti-Syrian figures continued and opponents of Assad’s regime say he has maintained his influence through allies who now control the government.

All this made the Aug. 9 arrest of former Information Minister Michel Samaha all the more shocking.

Samaha, one of Syria’s most loyal allies in Lebanon who has long acted as an unofficial media adviser to Assad, was plucked from his bed at dawn by special police forces who burst into his summer mountain home. Within hours, various leaks began emerging that Samaha had confessed to having personally transported explosives in his car from Syria to Lebanon with the purpose of killing Lebanese personalities at the behest of Syria.

Two days later, a military court indicted Samaha, along with Syrian Brig. Gen. Ali Mamlouk, of plotting to carry out terrorist attacks inside Lebanon. Mamlouk, who was appointed last month by Assad to head Syria’s National Security Bureau, was indicted in absentia on charges he furnished the explosives to Samaha.

According to a senior Lebanese police official, Samaha confessed after he was confronted with audio and video footage taken by a double agent using a camera-equipped pen. The official spoke on condition of anonymity in line with government regulations.

The case stunned many in Lebanon, where political assassinations have occurred with impunity for decades. While Syria has been blamed for many of the killings, no one has been held accountable.

Syria’s allies in Lebanon – including Hezbollah – were mostly silent following Samaha’s arrest, apparently believing that the evidence against him was solid.

“I think the policy (in Lebanon) has been shifting away from alliance with Syria,” said Ayham Kamel, a Middle East analyst at the Eurasia Group in London. “The Syrian regime has been under intense pressure, so its allies in Lebanon have recalibrated.”

Syria’s opponents in Lebanon cited the Samaha case as proof that Damascus was trying to incite sectarian strife in its neighbor to deflect attention from its own problems, and they called for the Syrian ambassador to be expelled.

In unusually bold comments by a Lebanese head of state, President Michel Suleiman said he expected Assad to explain the situation.

“When any relationship with a foreign entity harms Lebanon, we end it. And when the relationship is again in Lebanon’s interest, we reinstate it,” Suleiman said in an apparent reference to Syria. His comments were published in the Lebanese media.

Analysts say Suleiman is aiming to be the new face of a more independent Lebanon, taking advantage of a weakened regime in Syria.

Prime Minister Najib Mikati, who heads a government dominated by Hezbollah and pro-Syrian groups, said he isn’t taking sides in the Syria crisis, adopting a policy of “disassociation.” Critics say that has led to a general government paralysis in which authorities are afraid to take sides when it comes to Lebanon’s feuding pro- and anti-Syrian camps.

Mikati commended the security operation that resulted in Samaha’s arrest, saying it saved Lebanon from “major disaster.”

“The Syrian regime’s allies are shrinking. The Lebanese government, which was `Made in Syria,’ was among the regime’s last allies, and they seem to be losing even that,” said Hadi Hobeish, an anti-Syrian lawmaker.

Syria accuses Sunni groups in Lebanon of trying to establish a supply line to Syrian rebels across Lebanon’s northern frontier, bringing across fighters and weapons.

The Lebanese military has been deployed along the porous border area to try to prevent the smuggling efforts, but if Beirut turns against Damascus, such operations could become easier to carry out.

Even Hezbollah, the Shiite militant group backed by Iran and Syria, has sought to distance itself from the turmoil in Syria. When Shiite clans abducted scores of Syrians in Lebanon last week in retaliation for a kidnapping by Syrian rebels in Damascus, Hezbollah leader Sheikh Hassan Nasrallah said the mayhem was out of the group’s control.

Analysts say Assad still has the tools and the allies he needs to stir up trouble in Lebanon.

“I don’t think the Syrian regime has fully lost influence in Lebanon,” said Kamel, the Eurasia analyst. “But definitely it has less ability and even willingness to intervene on the same level in Lebanese politics,” he added.

Hanin Ghaddar, managing editor of the Lebanon opposition website NOWLebanon, said Lebanon is at a significant crossroads in its relationship with Syria.

“Assad’s aura in Lebanon is fading,” Ghaddar wrote last week.

By : Zeina Karam

Associated Press

Huffington Post

photo: In this Aug. 9, 2012 photo, Lebanese security forces stand at the entrance building of former Lebanese Information Minister Michel Samaha as they raid his house after they arrested him. Samaha an ardent supporter of President Bashar Assad who has long acted as his unofficial media adviser, was arrested in a dramatic, high profile police operation on August 9, 2012 and subsequently indicted for plotting terror attacks in Lebanon at Syria’s behest. The civil war in Syria is affecting its fragile, tiny neighbor Lebanon in countless ways and has already spilled over into sectarian street clashes, kidnappings and general government paralysis. (AP Photo)

Share:

Comments

31 responses to “Syrian civil war shakes Damascus-Beirut ties”

  1. Constantin7 Avatar
    Constantin7

    Personally, I don’t think that the Lebanese are so much dum to have a civil war in the country after so many years of civil war that hurt all communities and all regions. With war everybody is a looser and there are no winners, so I hope that the Lebanese have gained some sense of wisdom in this respect and avoid their country any civil strife.
    What is happening in Tripoli are skirmiches provoked by the majority in the city to avenge their “brother victims” in Syria. I cannot conceive that the minority in Tripoli would cause this strife, as it is completely against its interest. The over-zealous sunni cheikhs and their salafi supporters in Tripoli after a sermon in the mosque charged with hatred and violence, come out of the mosque ready to die for “God”, the jihad, and there re-starts the violence…. As simple as that. Unfortunately going to the mosque is like going to a hate-battery charger, everyone comes out of the mosque charged to kill, to refuse the other, to hate the other, to believe that he is better than the other and therefore is superior than the other, etc…..
    “Father: Forgive them as they don’t know what they are doing”, they really think they are serving God by killing in his name!!!
    Wow just unbelievable….and yet 1.5 billion believe it or should I say “have to” believe it !

    1. Boss .. Avatar

       Constantin7 .. Allow me to respond to your comment which you just have posted. It’s a bit sad that people like you ain’t doing much but to mislead people by your ignorance through the internet, and especially by saying that the mosque is like a “hate-battery charger”.. People are suffering and dying in Syria so therefore the Lebanese people are in there full rights to hate whats going on in Syria and be mad on the behalf of the Syrian people.. As the Prophet Muhammad Peace be upon Him, said “All Muslims are one body if only one part is hurt the whole body suffers ” This quote tells us that the Lebanese people are feeling as much pain as the Syrian people and therefore you are seing why people in Lebanon are acting the way they are..

      1. Leborigine Avatar
        Leborigine

        Excuse my ignorance, but are you fricken serious!! Not one single syrian during the Lebanese civil war cared for any Lebanese – NOT ONE. Every time I met a syrian and we discussed the war, the majority always said, into al-Libneniyeh badkon da3iss!. Plus, if your theory is sustainable, why aren’t the rest of the arabs or muslims hurting for the palestinians or the syrians?? The Lebanese Xtians were the only ones who paid the price for living in luxury while the palestinians were in refugee camps, but it was ok for the rest of the muslim world to live in luxury.
        I suggest that every Lebanese should get their head out of their own arse, have a look around and put Lebanon first on your agenda. If you want to beleive in God/Allah, then pray and keep it to yourself, and finally screw syria, KSA, iran, israel and the rest of the world, care factor zero if they all disappeared, but please do not give me this crap that they are feeling syria’s pain. The only pain I feel for is for the mothers and the children, but the government and FSA, they can all go to hell!

        1. Mahdi Kenaani Avatar
          Mahdi Kenaani

          never mind…

        2. Boss .. Avatar

           So just becuase some syrian people didn’t care about the lebanese people during the civil war , means that the lebanese people should give them the finger and be as cold hearted or what? Come on, you know better.. And what do you exactly mean by, that the muslims/arabs ain’t showing sympathy to the Syrian or the palestinian people ? Everyone are demonstrating, sending money and doing everything they are capable of to support the people in both Syria and Palestine, from all across the world, as here in Denmark(Europe) for an example. The reason why you haven’t seen reactions from the leaders in the muslim world, is because they are doing as the western world(America, Britain….) want them to, and it is to not interferere at all.. 2 Weeks before the uprising in Syria, Bashar Al-Assad was in the white house, suddenly NOW! the America are against him, that shows us what kind of hypocrisy that is going on in the Western World.. The same in Egypt it is well known that the US and Hosni Mubarak were very good allies through the years, but as soon as the Egyptian people were against him, they changed side and decided to go against him.. The same in Libya with Gaddafi and we can go on…

        3. Leborigine Avatar
          Leborigine

          @google-a534bbc7131266ce5f8e599230e958be:disqus I didn’t say that we shouldn’t care, I have also noted that I feel for the mothers and the children-isn;t that showing sympathy?? What I meant is no else is killing each other like we are for a few farts in syria.
          As well, who has paid a higher price than the Lebanese for the palestinian cause?? I agree everyone sends money and protest for them, but we lost lives from them and for them. Lebanon lost its identity for their cause, we had a civil war for their cause, we have armed militias for their cause, we are divided for their cause. Show me any arab country that has suffered as much since the creation of israel??
          Boss…, read my old posts and you will know who I am. I do not despise or degrade anyone unless they attack me, i just love my country and hate anyone who interferes in it. Is that too much to ask for?

      2. Leborigine Avatar
        Leborigine

        Excuse my ignorance, but are you fricken serious!! Not one single syrian during the Lebanese civil war cared for any Lebanese – NOT ONE. Every time I met a syrian and we discussed the war, the majority always said, into al-Libneniyeh badkon da3iss!. Plus, if your theory is sustainable, why aren’t the rest of the arabs or muslims hurting for the palestinians or the syrians?? The Lebanese Xtians were the only ones who paid the price for living in luxury while the palestinians were in refugee camps, but it was ok for the rest of the muslim world to live in luxury.
        I suggest that every Lebanese should get their head out of their own arse, have a look around and put Lebanon first on your agenda. If you want to beleive in God/Allah, then pray and keep it to yourself, and finally screw syria, KSA, iran, israel and the rest of the world, care factor zero if they all disappeared, but please do not give me this crap that they are feeling syria’s pain. The only pain I feel for is for the mothers and the children, but the government and FSA, they can all go to hell!

        1. Mahdi Kenaani Avatar
          Mahdi Kenaani

          never mind…

        2. Leborigine Avatar
          Leborigine

          @google-a534bbc7131266ce5f8e599230e958be:disqus I didn’t say that we shouldn’t care, I have also noted that I feel for the mothers and the children-isn;t that showing sympathy?? What I meant is no else is killing each other like we are for a few farts in syria.
          As well, who has paid a higher price than the Lebanese for the palestinian cause?? I agree everyone sends money and protest for them, but we lost lives from them and for them. Lebanon lost its identity for their cause, we had a civil war for their cause, we have armed militias for their cause, we are divided for their cause. Show me any arab country that has suffered as much since the creation of israel??
          Boss…, read my old posts and you will know who I am. I do not despise or degrade anyone unless they attack me, i just love my country and hate anyone who interferes in it. Is that too much to ask for?

      3. im sorry but this is not how you mourn or feel for those that suffer….hate is being preached on a day to day basis…i agree with constantin i dont believe that the allawites would be stupid enough to instigate anything considering they are a minority and are surrounded….each to their own how they want practice their religion but no religion teaches this…..you dont mourn the suffering by causing more suffering….from day one the army should have been deployed in the area and around the border with syria to stop whats going out and coming…god knows what has come in now….but again politics..look at the rest of the country why only here? theres sheiks calling for the forming of miltary councils and jihad etc…certain agendas are being played out and we are being used for it…..we had ours if this is what they have chosen then its up to them to stop it….hwere was everyone when the syrians were in lebanon or israel if the past has taught us anything its we have noone but each other…palestine for 70 years noone lifted a finger????? 

        1. Boss .. Avatar

          The Alawites is stupid enough in the fist place to support such a big dictator that is killing over 100 people a day. Hate is being preached against those how oppresses and kills there own people, which they are in they full rights to. What do you else want them to ? They want to make sure that such actions should not occur in the future by making people aware of the hypocrisy and that they from now on should expose and go against every single corrupt ruler, no matter what !.. We should not forget that people in thousands have been killed ever since the Arab uprising has start and we are still counting …

      4. im sorry but this is not how you mourn or feel for those that suffer….hate is being preached on a day to day basis…i agree with constantin i dont believe that the allawites would be stupid enough to instigate anything considering they are a minority and are surrounded….each to their own how they want practice their religion but no religion teaches this…..you dont mourn the suffering by causing more suffering….from day one the army should have been deployed in the area and around the border with syria to stop whats going out and coming…god knows what has come in now….but again politics..look at the rest of the country why only here? theres sheiks calling for the forming of miltary councils and jihad etc…certain agendas are being played out and we are being used for it…..we had ours if this is what they have chosen then its up to them to stop it….hwere was everyone when the syrians were in lebanon or israel if the past has taught us anything its we have noone but each other…palestine for 70 years noone lifted a finger????? 

        1. Boss .. Avatar

          The Alawites is stupid enough in the fist place to support such a big dictator that is killing over 100 people a day. Hate is being preached against those how oppresses and kills there own people, which they are in they full rights to. What do you else want them to ? They want to make sure that such actions should not occur in the future by making people aware of the hypocrisy and that they from now on should expose and go against every single corrupt ruler, no matter what !.. We should not forget that people in thousands have been killed ever since the Arab uprising has start and we are still counting …

      5. Mahdi Kenaani Avatar
        Mahdi Kenaani

        Exactly..

      6. 5thDrawer Avatar
        5thDrawer

        And someone WANTS them to feel the pain.
        The Friday marches of support were just marches … as they were in Syria originally … and each Friday they got bigger … until one day 300 marched down the dividing street (Syria Street) – no-man’s land if you wish – and the crowd seemed too big to somebody else, so they threw a grenade into it. Since then, the Friday ‘fun’ has increased … and extended into the next week.
        Takes two to tango, of course, but provocation by one pack of idiots which can’t be ignored by the other pack of idiots – and everyone ready to get their guns out, especially when the army of Lebanon which they don’t want to hear from tries to calm things – leads to the mess it is now with the snipers who will shoot at anyone walking and at army people sitting in a car having lunch or standing at one position. Size of weapons growing exponentially now.
        Constantine certainly has a point about Fridays. And it doesn’t sound like the ‘good word’ was ‘Peace’.
        The place will look like Allepo soon ….

      7. 5thDrawer Avatar
        5thDrawer

        And someone WANTS them to feel the pain.
        The Friday marches of support were just marches … as they were in Syria originally … and each Friday they got bigger … until one day 300 marched down the dividing street (Syria Street) – no-man’s land if you wish – and the crowd seemed too big to somebody else, so they threw a grenade into it. Since then, the Friday ‘fun’ has increased … and extended into the next week.
        Takes two to tango, of course, but provocation by one pack of idiots which can’t be ignored by the other pack of idiots – and everyone ready to get their guns out, especially when the army of Lebanon which they don’t want to hear from tries to calm things – leads to the mess it is now with the snipers who will shoot at anyone walking and at army people sitting in a car having lunch or standing at one position. Size of weapons growing exponentially now.
        Constantine certainly has a point about Fridays. And it doesn’t sound like the ‘good word’ was ‘Peace’.
        The place will look like Allepo soon ….

      8. you miss the point completely…has does lebanese killing lebanese solve syria or anyone elses problems? what is this going to acieve? you have clerics inciting violence…you have mp’s like merhab attacking the army…where were these people when israel was occupying lebanon? or syria? or when the palestinians were trying to take over? and please your comment that the arabs are doing what they can has been a load of crap since 1948…its ignorance like this that is breeding the violence….people in tripoli should be laying down their arms and demanding their politicians build the infrastructure there…roads,schools,drainage,employment,social services…how much money has been pumped into tripoli in the lsat 5 years? where has it gone? they syrians have chosen this path its up to them to resolve it…we had ours and in the end what did it achieve? 180000 dead and for what?? brother what is happening in tripoli is of no benefit to anyone it is not going to change anything….a young girl died falling down an elevator shaft the other day when she was fleeing…shou zamba what did she do??

  2. Constantin7 Avatar
    Constantin7

    Personally, I don’t think that the Lebanese are so much dum to have a civil war in the country after so many years of civil war that hurt all communities and all regions. With war everybody is a looser and there are no winners, so I hope that the Lebanese have gained some sense of wisdom in this respect and avoid their country any civil strife.
    What is happening in Tripoli are skirmiches provoked by the majority in the city to avenge their “brother victims” in Syria. I cannot conceive that the minority in Tripoli would cause this strife, as it is completely against its interest. The over-zealous sunni cheikhs and their salafi supporters in Tripoli after a sermon in the mosque charged with hatred and violence, come out of the mosque ready to die for “God”, the jihad, and there re-starts the violence…. As simple as that. Unfortunately going to the mosque is like going to a hate-battery charger, everyone comes out of the mosque charged to kill, to refuse the other, to hate the other, to believe that he is better than the other and therefore is superior than the other, etc…..
    “Father: Forgive them as they don’t know what they are doing”, they really think they are serving God by killing in his name!!!
    Wow just unbelievable….and yet 1.5 billion believe it or should I say “have to” believe it !

    1. Boss .. Avatar

       Constantin7 .. Allow me to respond to your comment which you just have posted. It’s a bit sad that people like you ain’t doing much but to mislead people by your ignorance through the internet, and especially by saying that the mosque is like a “hate-battery charger”.. People are suffering and dying in Syria so therefore the Lebanese people are in there full rights to hate whats going on in Syria and be mad on the behalf of the Syrian people.. As the Prophet Muhammad Peace be upon Him, said “All Muslims are one body if only one part is hurt the whole body suffers ” This quote tells us that the Lebanese people are feeling as much pain as the Syrian people and therefore you are seing why people in Lebanon are acting the way they are..

      1. Leborigine Avatar
        Leborigine

        Excuse my ignorance, but are you fricken serious!! Not one single syrian during the Lebanese civil war cared for any Lebanese – NOT ONE. Every time I met a syrian and we discussed the war, the majority always said, into al-Libneniyeh badkon da3iss!. Plus, if your theory is sustainable, why aren’t the rest of the arabs or muslims hurting for the palestinians or the syrians?? The Lebanese Xtians were the only ones who paid the price for living in luxury while the palestinians were in refugee camps, but it was ok for the rest of the muslim world to live in luxury.
        I suggest that every Lebanese should get their head out of their own arse, have a look around and put Lebanon first on your agenda. If you want to beleive in God/Allah, then pray and keep it to yourself, and finally screw syria, KSA, iran, israel and the rest of the world, care factor zero if they all disappeared, but please do not give me this crap that they are feeling syria’s pain. The only pain I feel for is for the mothers and the children, but the government and FSA, they can all go to hell!

        1. Mahdi Kenaani Avatar
          Mahdi Kenaani

          yeah its just that if every-fucking-body disappeared the lebanese will disappeaer too… no country can survive without the others

        2. Boss .. Avatar

           So just becuase some syrian people didn’t care about the lebanese people during the civil war , means that the lebanese people should give them the finger and be as cold hearted or what? Come on, you know better.. And what do you exactly mean by, that the muslims/arabs ain’t showing sympathy to the Syrian or the palestinian people ? Everyone are demonstrating, sending money and doing everything they are capable of to support the people in both Syria and Palestine, from all across the world, as here in Denmark(Europe) for an example. The reason why you haven’t seen reactions from the leaders in the muslim world, is because they are doing as the western world(America, Britain….) want them to, and it is to not interferere at all.. 2 Weeks before the uprising in Syria, Bashar Al-Assad was in the white house, suddenly NOW! the America are against him, that shows us what kind of hypocrisy that is going on in the Western World.. The same in Egypt it is well known that the US and Hosni Mubarak were very good allies through the years, but as soon as the Egyptian people were against him, they changed side and decided to go against him.. The same in Libya with Gaddafi and we can go on…

        3. Leborigine Avatar
          Leborigine

          @google-a534bbc7131266ce5f8e599230e958be:disqus I didn’t say that we shouldn’t care, I have also noted that I feel for the mothers and the children-isn;t that showing sympathy?? What I meant is no else is killing each other like we are for a few farts in syria.
          As well, who has paid a higher price than the Lebanese for the palestinian cause?? I agree everyone sends money and protest for them, but we lost lives from them and for them. Lebanon lost its identity for their cause, we had a civil war for their cause, we have armed militias for their cause, we are divided for their cause. Show me any arab country that has suffered as much since the creation of israel??
          Boss…, read my old posts and you will know who I am. I do not despise or degrade anyone unless they attack me, i just love my country and hate anyone who interferes in it. Is that too much to ask for?

      2. im sorry but this is not how you mourn or feel for those that suffer….hate is being preached on a day to day basis…i agree with constantin i dont believe that the allawites would be stupid enough to instigate anything considering they are a minority and are surrounded….each to their own how they want practice their religion but no religion teaches this…..you dont mourn the suffering by causing more suffering….from day one the army should have been deployed in the area and around the border with syria to stop whats going out and coming…god knows what has come in now….but again politics..look at the rest of the country why only here? theres sheiks calling for the forming of miltary councils and jihad etc…certain agendas are being played out and we are being used for it…..we had ours if this is what they have chosen then its up to them to stop it….hwere was everyone when the syrians were in lebanon or israel if the past has taught us anything its we have noone but each other…palestine for 70 years noone lifted a finger????? 

        1. Boss .. Avatar

          The Alawites is stupid enough in the fist place to support such a big dictator that is killing over 100 people a day. Hate is being preached against those how oppresses and kills there own people, which they are in they full rights to. What do you else want them to ? They want to make sure that such actions should not occur in the future by making people aware of the hypocrisy and that they from now on should expose and go against every single corrupt ruler, no matter what !.. We should not forget that people in thousands have been killed ever since the Arab uprising has start and we are still counting …

      3. Mahdi Kenaani Avatar
        Mahdi Kenaani

        Exactly..

      4. 5thDrawer Avatar
        5thDrawer

        And someone WANTS them to feel the pain.
        The Friday marches of support were just marches … as they were in Syria originally … and each Friday they got bigger … until one day 300 marched down the dividing street (Syria Street) – no-man’s land if you wish – and the crowd seemed too big to somebody else, so they threw a grenade into it. Since then, the Friday ‘fun’ has increased … and extended into the next week.Takes two to tango, of course, but provocation by one pack of idiots which can’t be ignored by the other pack of idiots – and everyone ready to get their guns out, especially when the army of Lebanon which they don’t want to hear from tries to calm things – leads to the mess it is now with the snipers who will shoot at anyone walking and at army people sitting in a car having lunch or standing at one position. Size of weapons growing exponentially now.
        Constantine certainly has a point about Fridays. And it doesn’t sound like the ‘good word’ was ‘Peace’.
        The place will look like Allepo soon ….

      5. you miss the point completely…has does lebanese killing lebanese solve syria or anyone elses problems? what is this going to acieve? you have clerics inciting violence…you have mp’s like merhab attacking the army…where were these people when israel was occupying lebanon? or syria? or when the palestinians were trying to take over? and please your comment that the arabs are doing what they can has been a load of crap since 1948…its ignorance like this that is breeding the violence….people in tripoli should be laying down their arms and demanding their politicians build the infrastructure there…roads,schools,drainage,employment,social services…how much money has been pumped into tripoli in the lsat 5 years? where has it gone? they syrians have chosen this path its up to them to resolve it…we had ours and in the end what did it achieve? 180000 dead and for what?? brother what is happening in tripoli is of no benefit to anyone it is not going to change anything….a young girl died falling down an elevator shaft the other day when she was fleeing…shou zamba what did she do??

Leave a Reply